Real Questions

“What Were My Dreams Trying to Tell Me?” by Ayad Akhtar.  Atlantic Monthly.  November 2026.

Homeland Elegies a novel by Ayad Akhtar.  Back Bay Books.  343 pp. $16.99.  *****

The Radiance a novel by Ayad Akhtar.  Summit Books.  286 pp.  $29.00.  *****

 

It started with an article in the Atlantic, one I might not have read except that I had time on my hands.  It was by a writer I’d never heard of (although he’d won a Pulitzer for drama and an American Book Award for his second novel) and concerned discovering his soul, a concept I’m not sure I believe in.  He discovered the process through dream work, which does interest me.  So I read on, captured by the excellence of the prose.

I have kept dream journals, but Akhtar—at the suggestion of a professor—actually tied a small pencil to his finger so that, when he woke up at night, he would jot down whatever he could remember of his most recent dream, a practice that I would think would lead to some restless nights.  I do know that the more you write down dreams, the more you remember them.

He began having dreams that predicted things, the first just a casual encounter, then more important things, including a dream that seemed to foreshadow what happened on September 11th.  Ayad is Pakistani-American and from a Muslim family, though he was not, and is not, a practicing Muslim.  But the idea that his mind could predict things was uncanny, to say the least.

From dreamwork he went on to other practices: he took a yoga class where, miraculously, the teacher emphasized meditation, and he got into that.  In all of these endeavors, he was reading ferociously, first Freud and Jung, then various meditative traditions, Hindus, Buddhists, Sufis.  These things happened over a period of months and years, but his meditation practice grew deep, to the point that it was life-changing and mind altering.  The article traces the experience that was the basis for much of what he wrote later, specifically in The Radiance.

But that book’s pub date was a month away when I read the article, so I got a hold of Homeland Elegies in the meantime.  Much of that book takes place during the period he described in the article, but its actual focus is the life of a Muslim-American in the days following September 11th, a harrowing story that was eye-opening for me to read.  It is also a portrait of his family and especially his larger-than-life father, who dominates that book, and dominated his life, as few fathers do.

The man was an immigrant, but proud to be an American and to live like one.  He was a successful physician, a heart specialist, who included among his patients none other than a businessman named Donald Trump (whom he admired and later voted for).  He was generous to the point of lunacy, often tipping 100% of the bill to the waiter, and once (how’s this for a tip?) giving his luxury car to a parking attendant.  He was a gambling addict—his son estimates somewhere that he lost $2,000,000 gambling—a philanderer who had a second family (unknown to the first), and, eventually, an alcoholic who drank to the point of incoherence.  Talk about contradictions in one man’s life.

But he also, to his great credit, supported his son in a writing career that took a long time getting started.  Ayad went to Brown and studied creative writing, determined to write, but did so without much success for the next twenty years.  He didn’t have any real success until he wrote his Pulitzer winning play in his early forties.  Since then it seems that everything he touches turns to gold.  (He even got a part in an HBO movie.)  But I must say, as someone who spent ten years going unpublished (more or less average for a novelist), I hugely admire a man who stuck to his guns that long, who wouldn’t give up on a career or compromise himself, though he needed financial support from his father.  All fathers should help their sons that way.

The Radiance is a different kind of novel altogether.  Homeland Elegies seems obviously, and intentionally, autobiographical; he uses his own name in the book, his father’s own name, and recounts the interactions with Donald Trump specifically.  But The Radiance opens with an event that is not mentioned in the Atlantic article and that seems, on the face of it, invented (though he continues to use his own name in this novel): while living in upstate New York, the protagonist is out riding a bicycle when he is hit—deliberately, it turns out—by a man driving a truck, is thrown through the air, and left for dead.  He did not die but was found by a nearby family who got him to the hospital in time.  He had to have his spleen removed, but he was otherwise okay, and is going through a slow recovery, living in his rented home, as the novel opens.

It is this accident, not a long-term meditation practice, that brings about alterations in his mind and body, what he refers to as the radiance in the title, though that doesn’t begin to describe the complexity of it.

Homeland Elegies is beautifully put together, but The Radiance seems—as other reviewers have noticed—to be several novels at once: the story of a life-altering accident that affects the protagonist’s mind and body, and that reflects elements from the past and the future; a campus novel about trying to teach creative writing students, or any other student, at a moment when academic life seems profoundly broken; a mystery novel about who was driving the truck, and why; and last but not least—I would actually put this first—the biography of a woman named Lucie Neroponte, whom Ayad loves but never has sex with, who is one of the most vibrant and fascinating characters I’ve ever encountered in fiction, and whose story runs through the whole book.  I would call her the victim of some of what happens, except that she is the kind of woman who never allows herself to be victimized, and always lands on her feet.

I was enthralled by every night that I read this novel, though I found the campus novel aspect deeply disturbing, as someone who taught at a university (in a minor adjunct post) for thirteen years, retiring in 2014.  The students Akhtar describes don’t seem interested in learning.  They’re so damaged by their experience, by a life where they’ve used various drugs to deal with their supposed difficulties (I’m not sure all these things are helped by drugs), so bewildered by the present and discouraged about the future that all they want to do is attack professors for some supposedly offensive teaching.  (Percy Shelley was a pedophile!  You actually want us to read him?)  They don’t want to be touched by their experience.  They want to avoid being hurt by it, to the point where they don’t want experience at all.  It’s an impossible situation for learning.

The one exception is a young woman named Susan Yi, who has long been a student of Lucie’s and becomes Ayad’s student when he substitutes for a professor on leave (the name of the institution isn’t specified, though AO Scott in his review seems convinced it is Bard).  She’s Chinese-American, adopted by a woman whom Lucie calls bat-shit crazy, and though she has been damaged in the same way that all her classmates have, she nevertheless wants to learn and is a voracious reader, perhaps a tad arrogant (arrogance being the last refuge of the insecure).  In the middle of this novel, in a conference with Ayad that abounds in pitfalls, she exclaims at one point, “Why isn’t anyone open to a real question anymore?” and, as if to illustrate that, asks Ayad if he believes in God.  That basic human question seems so loaded to Ayad that he doesn’t answer it (I’m not sure what his answer would be).  But I took it as a human cry in the midst of a desperate situation: could somebody around here please be real with me?

I found The Radiance  captivating, to say the least, but was puzzled, I would almost say dissatisfied, by the way it ended.  It wasn’t that I felt something was wrong.  I felt I had missed something.  So I decided to read the book again (something I have done very few times in my life).  And I would say at this point that I found the thing I’d missed, I went through the whole experience again and was able to absorb it more fully (a lot of what this novel is about is Ayad absorbing his experience), and in my mind at least, that conference with Susan Yi is somehow central.  She isn’t a screwed-up student who is looking for help from a professor (though she is all of that).  She’s a human being asking herself the fundamental questions: why is there something rather than nothing?  Why this particular something?  How, then, are we supposed to live?

Susan seeks answers to those questions, as does Ayad, and Lucie.  That’ s what this novel is about, the different ways they seek answers.  It takes spiritual life and the big questions seriously in a way that few contemporary novels do.  It doesn’t come up with answers.  But it beautifully faces the questions.